PDA

View Full Version : Does a clean install of XP Pro overwite data on hard drive?


Stephen R
December 5th 03, 12:39 AM
Does a full install of XP on an exisitng 2000 machine
that has boot problems overwite data on a single
partititioned NTFS hard disk?

____________________________________________

Backgroud:-

A friend who lives in a remote location has a Win2000 pro
installation that has corrupted and will not boot.

She has since bought Win XP Pro (full version) and would
like to install this but not overwite the data on drive c
as unfortunately she has not backed up in some time and
has data both in directories off the root and in
directories on her desktop (this is a 30Gb drive
partitioned as a single drive using NTFS).

As all attempts to fix the boot problem using Win 2000
recovery console have failed (fixboot, fixmbr, replacing
pagefile.sys etc) and she has not made an Emergency
Repair Disc. She can see data directories on the C:
drive but cannot change to anything but WINNT and entire
directories are way too big to copy onto floppies.

She has started an install using the XP CD and, as she
cannot start her existing operating system, is not
offered the choice of upgrading and can only perform a
full install. She went with this as far as setup asking
her about disk partitioning and chickened out worried
that this would format the hard drive. Does it?

At this moment I have told her to hold off and wait till
the end of next week when another tech minded friend is
visiting and have him remove the hard disk and run it as
a slave on another machine to save the data and this is
indeed a good option, however she is anxious to acces
some of the data as soon as possible to work on it.

If XP can clean install without overwiting the data she
can then save the precious data by transferring it to
another 2000 machine on her home network.

I would be extremely grateful for any advice.

Stephen

HillBillyBuddhist
December 5th 03, 12:39 AM
Yes.

D


"Stephen R" > wrote in message
...
> Does a full install of XP on an exisitng 2000 machine
> that has boot problems overwite data on a single
> partititioned NTFS hard disk?
>
> ____________________________________________
>
> Backgroud:-
>
> A friend who lives in a remote location has a Win2000 pro
> installation that has corrupted and will not boot.
>
> She has since bought Win XP Pro (full version) and would
> like to install this but not overwite the data on drive c
> as unfortunately she has not backed up in some time and
> has data both in directories off the root and in
> directories on her desktop (this is a 30Gb drive
> partitioned as a single drive using NTFS).
>
> As all attempts to fix the boot problem using Win 2000
> recovery console have failed (fixboot, fixmbr, replacing
> pagefile.sys etc) and she has not made an Emergency
> Repair Disc. She can see data directories on the C:
> drive but cannot change to anything but WINNT and entire
> directories are way too big to copy onto floppies.
>
> She has started an install using the XP CD and, as she
> cannot start her existing operating system, is not
> offered the choice of upgrading and can only perform a
> full install. She went with this as far as setup asking
> her about disk partitioning and chickened out worried
> that this would format the hard drive. Does it?
>
> At this moment I have told her to hold off and wait till
> the end of next week when another tech minded friend is
> visiting and have him remove the hard disk and run it as
> a slave on another machine to save the data and this is
> indeed a good option, however she is anxious to acces
> some of the data as soon as possible to work on it.
>
> If XP can clean install without overwiting the data she
> can then save the precious data by transferring it to
> another 2000 machine on her home network.
>
> I would be extremely grateful for any advice.
>
> Stephen

Dan DeStefano
December 5th 03, 12:39 AM
this depends on how you install windows. if you choose to install on the
same disk and install windows in the default directory, then you will not
loose any data. windows 2000 installs into the "winnt" directory, while
windows xp installs into the "windows" directory. simply installing windows
xp will not overwrite the windows 2000 installation, but it will overwrite
the boot files (system partition) so, yes, this will fix your bootup
problem.

however, i recommend that, after installing xp and recovering and backing up
all of your data, that you format your disk and do a clean installation.
this will help to mitigate the problems with installing xp over w2k -
duplicate profile folders and residual files/folders from w2k, as well as
the winnt directory taking up a lot of hdd space.

Dan DeStefano


"Stephen R" > wrote in message
...
> Does a full install of XP on an exisitng 2000 machine
> that has boot problems overwite data on a single
> partititioned NTFS hard disk?
>
> ____________________________________________
>
> Backgroud:-
>
> A friend who lives in a remote location has a Win2000 pro
> installation that has corrupted and will not boot.
>
> She has since bought Win XP Pro (full version) and would
> like to install this but not overwite the data on drive c
> as unfortunately she has not backed up in some time and
> has data both in directories off the root and in
> directories on her desktop (this is a 30Gb drive
> partitioned as a single drive using NTFS).
>
> As all attempts to fix the boot problem using Win 2000
> recovery console have failed (fixboot, fixmbr, replacing
> pagefile.sys etc) and she has not made an Emergency
> Repair Disc. She can see data directories on the C:
> drive but cannot change to anything but WINNT and entire
> directories are way too big to copy onto floppies.
>
> She has started an install using the XP CD and, as she
> cannot start her existing operating system, is not
> offered the choice of upgrading and can only perform a
> full install. She went with this as far as setup asking
> her about disk partitioning and chickened out worried
> that this would format the hard drive. Does it?
>
> At this moment I have told her to hold off and wait till
> the end of next week when another tech minded friend is
> visiting and have him remove the hard disk and run it as
> a slave on another machine to save the data and this is
> indeed a good option, however she is anxious to acces
> some of the data as soon as possible to work on it.
>
> If XP can clean install without overwiting the data she
> can then save the precious data by transferring it to
> another 2000 machine on her home network.
>
> I would be extremely grateful for any advice.
>
> Stephen

Google