If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the
first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. |
Ads |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
The surest way is to uplug the system. You did not mention whether or not
your internet connection is passing through a surge protector also. -- Colin Barnhorst [MVP Windows - Virtual Machine] (Reply to the group only unless otherwise requested) "Happy" wrote in message ... What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in =
stand=20 by, or leave on?=20 None of the above protect you. Computers, like TVs don't turn off. A = switch normally switches 1 of three wires and can spark anyway. Nothing = will protect you from a lightening strike. Power surges are caused by = many things (don't live near factories). A lightening caused power surge = is caused by lightening a long way away. In first world countries you don't need to worry about it. I believe = many US people have third world power. If so yank all plugs out. Only = my computer is protected and I only pull the plug out sometimes. My = other electrical devices I don't bother and they don't complain and they = aren't protected (a TV is 1/8th the price of a computer). --=20 ---------------------------------------------------------- http://www.microscum.com/mscommunity/ "Happy" wrote in message = ... What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? = (obviously the=20 first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in = stand=20 by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a = repeat.=20 =20 =20 |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
Happy wrote:
What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? Only fully safe way is to unplug ALL plugs. (Ive seen systems zapped via the ethernet plug and via the ground wire!) Shutdown is marginally more safe than hibernate. (Hibernate allows certain things to wake up the computer.) Finally, step AWAY from the computer! |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
On Mon, 21 Feb 2005 18:26:05 GMT, Happy wrote:
What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. There is a BIOS setting on most systems that lets you choose what the system should do if there is a loss and subsequent return of power. The default setting on most systems is to start up again. I change that setting to "stay off." Reason: When power is restored from an outage, there may be several fits of on again /off again until it returns completely. Watched one system, one time trying to honor the default setting. It was painful to see and now make a point of changing that setting. -- Sharon F MS-MVP ~ Windows Shell/User |
#6
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
Happy wrote:
What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. I think the others have covered the best option..unplug everything. But short of that you could use an uninterruptible power source. A good UPS will provide enough battery time to shut your system down gracefully during a power outage and provide "clean" power to your system. Look for one that kicks in when the power goes to high OR too low (brownout). Some also have software included that will automatically shutdown your system for you. gls858 |
#7
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
In ,
Happy had this to say: What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. In addition to all the other valid information given you should consider replacing your surge protector every once in a while. MOST surge protection devices have a light on them that make you think they are working. However, after a single surge the protection offered by the device is minimal if any yet the light will remain on and be happy to allow you to think that you're still protected. It's been my best interest, since days of yore, to not worry about expense and to use both a UPS and a surge protector. I've never lost a computer to a power surge though I've replaced a number of motherboards and chips with funny burnt ion smells that other people have brought by. I buy the best protection I can at the place I'm shopping and worry about the price later. $150 is a small price to pay to keep a $2500 custom PC protected. Often times I'll cheat and put the surge protector on one side of the UPS and one on the other end where the power leaves prior to going into my computer. A bit much? Probably but I can't think of any good reason to not do so. Galen -- "My mind rebels at stagnation. Give me problems, give me work, give me the most abstruse cryptogram or the most intricate analysis, and I am in my own proper atmosphere. I can dispense then with artificial stimulants. But I abhor the dull routine of existence. I crave for mental exaltation." -- Sherlock Holmes |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
These are a bunch of great solutions! After the past problems I have had, I
am going to be safe as well. But, do you mean you mean you unplug every nite, or just when there is a storm in the area? I will check the BIOS, I think that's why I lost the last one, a series of off & on in a short space of time. Any suggestions on software for use with a UPS? "Galen" wrote in message ... In , Happy had this to say: What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. In addition to all the other valid information given you should consider replacing your surge protector every once in a while. MOST surge protection devices have a light on them that make you think they are working. However, after a single surge the protection offered by the device is minimal if any yet the light will remain on and be happy to allow you to think that you're still protected. It's been my best interest, since days of yore, to not worry about expense and to use both a UPS and a surge protector. I've never lost a computer to a power surge though I've replaced a number of motherboards and chips with funny burnt ion smells that other people have brought by. I buy the best protection I can at the place I'm shopping and worry about the price later. $150 is a small price to pay to keep a $2500 custom PC protected. Often times I'll cheat and put the surge protector on one side of the UPS and one on the other end where the power leaves prior to going into my computer. A bit much? Probably but I can't think of any good reason to not do so. Galen -- "My mind rebels at stagnation. Give me problems, give me work, give me the most abstruse cryptogram or the most intricate analysis, and I am in my own proper atmosphere. I can dispense then with artificial stimulants. But I abhor the dull routine of existence. I crave for mental exaltation." -- Sherlock Holmes |
#9
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
Just need drivers (so windows and the UPS can talk to each other). =
Windows supports UPS. --=20 ---------------------------------------------------------- http://www.microscum.com/mscommunity/ "Happy" wrote in message = ... These are a bunch of great solutions! After the past problems I have = had, I=20 am going to be safe as well. But, do you mean you mean you unplug = every=20 nite, or just when there is a storm in the area? I will check the BIOS, I think that's why I lost the last one, a = series of=20 off & on in a short space of time. Any suggestions on software for use with a UPS? "Galen" wrote in message=20 ... In , Happy had this to say: What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. In addition to all the other valid information given you should = consider replacing your surge protector every once in a while. MOST surge=20 protection devices have a light on them that make you think they are working.=20 However, after a single surge the protection offered by the device is minimal = if=20 any yet the light will remain on and be happy to allow you to think that=20 you're still protected. It's been my best interest, since days of yore, to = not worry about expense and to use both a UPS and a surge protector. I've = never lost a computer to a power surge though I've replaced a number of motherboards and chips with funny burnt ion smells that other people = have brought by. I buy the best protection I can at the place I'm shopping = and worry about the price later. $150 is a small price to pay to keep a = $2500 custom PC protected. Often times I'll cheat and put the surge = protector on one side of the UPS and one on the other end where the power leaves = prior=20 to going into my computer. A bit much? Probably but I can't think of any = good reason to not do so. Galen --=20 "My mind rebels at stagnation. Give me problems, give me work, give = me the most abstruse cryptogram or the most intricate analysis, and I am in my own proper atmosphere. I can dispense then with artificial stimulants. But I abhor the dull routine of existence. I crave for mental exaltation." -- Sherlock Holmes =20 =20 =20 |
#10
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
My 2¢ worth:
a. Have an electrician (1) check your home electrical system for proper grounding. The National Electrical Code now requires that all wiring entering a residence be connected to the main grounding device [used to be telephones had their own separate ground rod (I have a DirectTV Satellite Dish wire, TV rooftop antenna, and telephone line all connected to a satellite receiver which in turn is connected to a DVD player, stereo/home theater receiver, VCR, and CD Player]; (2) Install a whole house surge protector [in the main electrical box or at the meter base](this protects against outside power surges inbound via electric lines). That way the in surge protectors at the equipment protect against relatively minor surges generated inside the house. Two of the reasons for the code changes are that (1) so much electronic equipment is now interconnected to several sources of potential surges [as I said above, satellite dish (18 AWG copper wire), telephone line (four to eight 24-26 AWG copper wires), and electrical power (usually 12 or 14 or 16 AWG copper wire), and note I do not mention cable service. (2) Most surge protectors divert the surge [an electrical current] to the building ground. These currents, like water, follow the easiest path .. Another way to phrase it is that electrical current will flow to the path of least resistance. That means that if you have a telephone line connected to a ground rod which is separate from the ground rod to which the electrical current is connected and a satellite dish, etc, AND they are all connected to one of your electronic devices you have the possibility of erroneous flow and burnout. b. No matter what, a dead-on direct lightning strike will get most of your connected stuff no matter what you do. Gene K Happy wrote: What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
Just when there is a storm occurring that brings the possibility of a
lighting strike. Gene K Happy wrote: These are a bunch of great solutions! After the past problems I have had, I am going to be safe as well. But, do you mean you mean you unplug every nite, or just when there is a storm in the area? I will check the BIOS, I think that's why I lost the last one, a series of off & on in a short space of time. Any suggestions on software for use with a UPS? "Galen" wrote in message ... In , Happy had this to say: What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. In addition to all the other valid information given you should consider replacing your surge protector every once in a while. MOST surge protection devices have a light on them that make you think they are working. However, after a single surge the protection offered by the device is minimal if any yet the light will remain on and be happy to allow you to think that you're still protected. It's been my best interest, since days of yore, to not worry about expense and to use both a UPS and a surge protector. I've never lost a computer to a power surge though I've replaced a number of motherboards and chips with funny burnt ion smells that other people have brought by. I buy the best protection I can at the place I'm shopping and worry about the price later. $150 is a small price to pay to keep a $2500 custom PC protected. Often times I'll cheat and put the surge protector on one side of the UPS and one on the other end where the power leaves prior to going into my computer. A bit much? Probably but I can't think of any good reason to not do so. Galen -- "My mind rebels at stagnation. Give me problems, give me work, give me the most abstruse cryptogram or the most intricate analysis, and I am in my own proper atmosphere. I can dispense then with artificial stimulants. But I abhor the dull routine of existence. I crave for mental exaltation." -- Sherlock Holmes |
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
If the strike is close enough, even disconnecting the power cord may not
prevent damage. That is the one thing that just cannot be helped except by insurance and keeping a backup on media stored elsewhere. -- Colin Barnhorst [MVP Windows - Virtual Machine] (Reply to the group only unless otherwise requested) "Not Me" wrote in message ... Just when there is a storm occurring that brings the possibility of a lighting strike. Gene K Happy wrote: These are a bunch of great solutions! After the past problems I have had, I am going to be safe as well. But, do you mean you mean you unplug every nite, or just when there is a storm in the area? I will check the BIOS, I think that's why I lost the last one, a series of off & on in a short space of time. Any suggestions on software for use with a UPS? "Galen" wrote in message ... In , Happy had this to say: What is the best way to prevent against power surge problems? (obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly) Is it better to shut off your computer, put it in hibernate, put it in stand by, or leave on? What are the risks? I have lost two computers in the last 5 years, and want to avoid a repeat. In addition to all the other valid information given you should consider replacing your surge protector every once in a while. MOST surge protection devices have a light on them that make you think they are working. However, after a single surge the protection offered by the device is minimal if any yet the light will remain on and be happy to allow you to think that you're still protected. It's been my best interest, since days of yore, to not worry about expense and to use both a UPS and a surge protector. I've never lost a computer to a power surge though I've replaced a number of motherboards and chips with funny burnt ion smells that other people have brought by. I buy the best protection I can at the place I'm shopping and worry about the price later. $150 is a small price to pay to keep a $2500 custom PC protected. Often times I'll cheat and put the surge protector on one side of the UPS and one on the other end where the power leaves prior to going into my computer. A bit much? Probably but I can't think of any good reason to not do so. Galen -- "My mind rebels at stagnation. Give me problems, give me work, give me the most abstruse cryptogram or the most intricate analysis, and I am in my own proper atmosphere. I can dispense then with artificial stimulants. But I abhor the dull routine of existence. I crave for mental exaltation." -- Sherlock Holmes |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
You have received numerous erroneous responses often
promoted by myths and clearly not based in first learning the science. For example, if nearby strikes were so destructive even to unplugged equipment, then every TV and every car radio is damaged during every nearby strike. Notice an anomaly in the assumption? Most of your responses were only personal speculation. The human is one of the most unreliable entities in the home. He is only available, at most, 1/3rd of a day. He cannot unplug everything including phone, smoke detector, dimmer switch, or dishwasher. And then there is the limit on number of times a wall outlet can be reconnected. Too many reasons say unplugging is not practical nor effective. Your own assumption, "obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly" is classic junk science reasoning. You have assumed surge protector and surge protection are same. They are not. A surge protection 'system' may or may not have a surge protector. The surge protector is not surge protection AND in some cases is not even necessary in that 'system'. Surge protection is earth ground. Not Me accurately introduced the concept. The one component that every surge protection 'system' must have is a single point earth ground. BTW - why single point? So that surges do not enter a building via ground. What do those grossly overpriced, undersized, and ineffective plug-in protectors not mention? Earth ground. Why? They do not even claim to provide effective protection. They hope you will assume "surge protector = surge protection". You did just that. You promoted a myth that has people paying $15 and $50 per appliance for ineffective protection. Effective solution costs about $1 per appliance. BTW, why do some recommend periodically replacing protectors? Because the plug-in protectors that don't have earth ground, are also grossly expensive and undersize protection. Too few joules. Effective protection is also properly sized. Plug-in protectors get recommended by the naive when the protector is grossly undersized - and must frequently be replaced. Even before WWII, buildings were protected from nearby and direct lightning strikes without damage. Your telco connects a $multi-million computer to overhead wires everywhere in town. Do they unplug that switching computer during every thunderstorm? Of course not. No damage from direct or nearby lightning strikes. They don't use plug-in protectors. They earth - what those ineffective protectors hope you don't learn about. Protection is about connecting to earth ground before a destructive transient can enter the building. Protection that typically costs about $1 per protected appliance. Appliances already contain any protection that works at the appliance. Just another detail those plug-in manufacturer forgot to mention. That internal protection assumes YOU have earthed a direct lightning strike before it can enter the building. If you don't, then that internal appliance protection may be overwhelmed. Again, Not Me reported how effective protection, 24/7, without human intervention, makes nearby and direct lightning strikes irrelevant. Even Home Depot sells the Intermatic IG1240RC 'whole house' protector for at least 10 years now. Lowes now sells equivalent models from Cutler Hammer and the new GE product (the old GE protector was undersized). Other effective units are sold by Leviton, Square D and so many other - for so many decades. This is well proven stuff. However too many humans are just experts - facts and the underlying concepts be damned. They saw the expression "surge protector" on a retail store shelve and now are experts on effective protection? Notice the manufacturer never mentions THE most critical component in every protection 'system': single point earthing. 'Whole house' protectors, properly earthed, are so effective that your phone company installs one, for free, where their line enters your building. Your cable needs no 'whole house' protector because it makes a direct connection to earth ground. That is what the effective protector does. It connects 'less than 10 foot' to a single point earth ground - THE protection. A protector must make a short, direct, and independent connection to single point earthing. What so many never mentioned: earthing. What those grossly overpriced, pathetically undersized plug-in protectors don't even discuss: earthing. No earth ground means no effective protection. And that, sir, is your bottom line. A surge protector is only as effective as its earth ground. Earthing is what keeps lightning from overwhelming the protection already installed in appliances. Effective protection means no appliance damage from any lighting - as has been proven by man most everywhere in the world since long before WWII. BTW, that BIOS recommendation should be unnecessary. A power supply controller on a properly designed motherboard must lock out the system when such power cycling problems occur. The UPS - is only for data protection from blackouts and extreme brownouts. It does claim to provide hardware protection. And then we look at missing facts. It does not claim protection from the one type of transient that typically damages electronics. Again, it is the things they forget to mention - ie earth ground - that says a UPS does not provide effective hardware protection. That UPS is only for data protection. Happy wrote: These are a bunch of great solutions! After the past problems I have had, I am going to be safe as well. But, do you mean you mean you unplug every nite, or just when there is a storm in the area? I will check the BIOS, I think that's why I lost the last one, a series of off & on in a short space of time. Any suggestions on software for use with a UPS? |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
A decent, if derisive, description of the issues. The only thing I'd add
is that most surge protectors actually do have an MOV in them, which clips off the amplitude above/below a specified level. One problem out there, though, is that there is a difference between a surge protector and a power strip - but they look the same. Many folks buy power strips that do nothing for clipping off extreme signal amplitude, thinking that they're getting surge protection - because they're much cheaper. grep w_tom wrote: You have received numerous erroneous responses often promoted by myths and clearly not based in first learning the science. For example, if nearby strikes were so destructive even to unplugged equipment, then every TV and every car radio is damaged during every nearby strike. Notice an anomaly in the assumption? Most of your responses were only personal speculation. The human is one of the most unreliable entities in the home. He is only available, at most, 1/3rd of a day. He cannot unplug everything including phone, smoke detector, dimmer switch, or dishwasher. And then there is the limit on number of times a wall outlet can be reconnected. Too many reasons say unplugging is not practical nor effective. Your own assumption, "obviously the first is to have the proper surge protector, and use it properly" is classic junk science reasoning. You have assumed surge protector and surge protection are same. They are not. A surge protection 'system' may or may not have a surge protector. The surge protector is not surge protection AND in some cases is not even necessary in that 'system'. Surge protection is earth ground. Not Me accurately introduced the concept. The one component that every surge protection 'system' must have is a single point earth ground. BTW - why single point? So that surges do not enter a building via ground. What do those grossly overpriced, undersized, and ineffective plug-in protectors not mention? Earth ground. Why? They do not even claim to provide effective protection. They hope you will assume "surge protector = surge protection". You did just that. You promoted a myth that has people paying $15 and $50 per appliance for ineffective protection. Effective solution costs about $1 per appliance. BTW, why do some recommend periodically replacing protectors? Because the plug-in protectors that don't have earth ground, are also grossly expensive and undersize protection. Too few joules. Effective protection is also properly sized. Plug-in protectors get recommended by the naive when the protector is grossly undersized - and must frequently be replaced. Even before WWII, buildings were protected from nearby and direct lightning strikes without damage. Your telco connects a $multi-million computer to overhead wires everywhere in town. Do they unplug that switching computer during every thunderstorm? Of course not. No damage from direct or nearby lightning strikes. They don't use plug-in protectors. They earth - what those ineffective protectors hope you don't learn about. Protection is about connecting to earth ground before a destructive transient can enter the building. Protection that typically costs about $1 per protected appliance. Appliances already contain any protection that works at the appliance. Just another detail those plug-in manufacturer forgot to mention. That internal protection assumes YOU have earthed a direct lightning strike before it can enter the building. If you don't, then that internal appliance protection may be overwhelmed. Again, Not Me reported how effective protection, 24/7, without human intervention, makes nearby and direct lightning strikes irrelevant. Even Home Depot sells the Intermatic IG1240RC 'whole house' protector for at least 10 years now. Lowes now sells equivalent models from Cutler Hammer and the new GE product (the old GE protector was undersized). Other effective units are sold by Leviton, Square D and so many other - for so many decades. This is well proven stuff. However too many humans are just experts - facts and the underlying concepts be damned. They saw the expression "surge protector" on a retail store shelve and now are experts on effective protection? Notice the manufacturer never mentions THE most critical component in every protection 'system': single point earthing. 'Whole house' protectors, properly earthed, are so effective that your phone company installs one, for free, where their line enters your building. Your cable needs no 'whole house' protector because it makes a direct connection to earth ground. That is what the effective protector does. It connects 'less than 10 foot' to a single point earth ground - THE protection. A protector must make a short, direct, and independent connection to single point earthing. What so many never mentioned: earthing. What those grossly overpriced, pathetically undersized plug-in protectors don't even discuss: earthing. No earth ground means no effective protection. And that, sir, is your bottom line. A surge protector is only as effective as its earth ground. Earthing is what keeps lightning from overwhelming the protection already installed in appliances. Effective protection means no appliance damage from any lighting - as has been proven by man most everywhere in the world since long before WWII. BTW, that BIOS recommendation should be unnecessary. A power supply controller on a properly designed motherboard must lock out the system when such power cycling problems occur. The UPS - is only for data protection from blackouts and extreme brownouts. It does claim to provide hardware protection. And then we look at missing facts. It does not claim protection from the one type of transient that typically damages electronics. Again, it is the things they forget to mention - ie earth ground - that says a UPS does not provide effective hardware protection. That UPS is only for data protection. Happy wrote: These are a bunch of great solutions! After the past problems I have had, I am going to be safe as well. But, do you mean you mean you unplug every nite, or just when there is a storm in the area? I will check the BIOS, I think that's why I lost the last one, a series of off & on in a short space of time. Any suggestions on software for use with a UPS? |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Power surge safety
"Most surge protectors actually do have an MOV in them,
which clips off the amplitude above/ [not]below a specified level." Correct. And now we define the circuit that includes those MOVs. A destructive transient seeks earth ground. It comes down AC mains. MOV adjacent to computer sees same voltage on both leads. IOW the 100+ amp transient creates no voltage across the MOV. With no voltage difference, the MOV sees nothing. Meanwhile that transient passes destructively through an adjacent computer - powered on or off. Or a destructive transient travels down only black (hot) AC wire. What does the MOV (adjacent to computer) do? Shunt (short, connect) that transient to all other wires. Now the transient has even more paths to find earth ground destructively via the computer - because the MOV was too close to transistors. BTW, this AC mains transient is a most common source of computer modem damage. Incoming on AC mains. Outgoing to earth ground via phone line. MOV either sees no voltage difference and does nothing, or MOV provides that destructive transients with more wires to enter and damage the adjacent (and powered off) computer. IOW a plug-in protector can even contribute to damage of the adjacent computer. So a manufacturer does not to discuss this or earthing. He hopes others will 'assume' the MOVs stop, block, or absorb the transient. They even hope you will assume the protector is a series mode device. Plug-in protectors are shunt mode devices. Just more facts he prefers we do not discuss. MOVs do not provide protection. Every incoming wire must connect to earth before entering the building. Some wires connect directly to single point earth (ie CATV and satellite dish). Other wires must make that earthing connection via a surge protector (ie MOVs); the 'whole house' protector. Protector does not provide protection. MOVs are effective when a typically destructive transient is connected short (less than 10 feet) to earth ground. IOW MOVs inside a power strip are ineffective as well as undersized. Nothing new in a concept that has been routine in telephone switching centers (Central Office or CO) and radio communication stations for long before WWII. For example, the CO prefers each incoming wire earthed 50 meters (150 feet) before the computer. (Notice facts provided with numbers.) Separation provides better protection. Any protection effective at an appliance is already inside that appliance. Internal protection that assumes a building has all incoming utility wires connected short to a common earth ground - 'whole house' protection. An MOV that connect each incoming wire to earth ground is effective. The MOV is also effective when it is properly sized - sufficient joules. Since a plug-in protector provide no effective earthing, then no reason to properly size the MOV. Plug-in protectors are often undersized (too few joules) as well as overpriced and ineffective. Such protectors are very profitable for the manufacturer - as long as we don't learn additional facts. grep wrote: A decent, if derisive, description of the issues. The only thing I'd add is that most surge protectors actually do have an MOV in them, which clips off the amplitude above/below a specified level. One problem out there, though, is that there is a difference between a surge protector and a power strip - but they look the same. Many folks buy power strips that do nothing for clipping off extreme signal amplitude, thinking that they're getting surge protection - because they're much cheaper. |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Power Surge On Hub Port ballon on connect... | Winux P | General XP issues or comments | 3 | June 10th 05 06:26 PM |
Power Surge | oh6a | Hardware and Windows XP | 0 | January 30th 05 06:37 PM |
power surge | oh6a | Windows XP Help and Support | 2 | January 29th 05 06:51 PM |
When electricity goes off suddenly does it damage my windows XP installation? | dev | General XP issues or comments | 52 | December 31st 04 02:24 AM |
Power Surge Error Message | Bo Donna | Hardware and Windows XP | 0 | September 29th 04 04:41 AM |