|
| If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|||||||
|
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
|
#1
March 5th 21, 05:28 AM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
Someone posted about the project:
https://github.com/JochenKalmbach/communitybridge3 I wonder if the "official" forum is still friendly to newsgroup posters. And is it possible that MS delete microsoft.* hierarchy in Usenet, at least in backbone servers? -- Regards, Lu Wei IM: PGP: 0xA12FEF7592CCE1EA 
|
| Ads |
|
#2
March 5th 21, 10:19 AM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
|
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
On Fri, 5 Mar 2021 13:28:37 +0800, Lu Wei wrote:
Someone posted about the project: https://github.com/JochenKalmbach/communitybridge3 I wonder if the "official" forum is still friendly to newsgroup posters. And is it possible that MS delete microsoft.* hierarchy in Usenet, at least in backbone servers? NNTP bridge? Hasn't Microsoft news server been shutdown quite a long time ago?
|
|
#3
March 5th 21, 08:26 PM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
|
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
On Fri, 5 Mar 2021 17:19:13 +0700, JJ wrote:
On Fri, 5 Mar 2021 13:28:37 +0800, Lu Wei wrote: Someone posted about the project: https://github.com/JochenKalmbach/communitybridge3 I wonder if the "official" forum is still friendly to newsgroup posters. And is it possible that MS delete microsoft.* hierarchy in Usenet, at least in backbone servers? NNTP bridge? Hasn't Microsoft news server been shutdown quite a long time ago? The Microsoft news server was shut down many years ago, but that is not relevant to the NNTP bridge. The NNTP bridge does not use the Microsoft news server. ****[Diagram*best*viewed*in*a*fixed-pitch*font] ***|===========*YOUR*COMPUTER*============| *********|======*THE*INTERNET*=====| ****+--------+*****************+--------+**********************+-------------+ ****¦**news**¦**NNTP*protocol**¦* *NNTP**¦***REST*web*service***¦**Mi crosoft**¦ ****¦*reader*¦---------------¦*bridge*¦--------------------¦**web*forum**¦ ****¦*client*¦************** ***¦********¦************ **********¦***server****¦ ****+--------+*****************+--------+**********************+-------------+ -- Kind regards Ralph
|
|
#4
March 5th 21, 09:09 PM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
|
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
On Fri, 5 Mar 2021 13:28:37 +0800, Lu Wei wrote:
Someone posted about the project: https://github.com/JochenKalmbach/communitybridge3 I wonder if the "official" forum is still friendly to newsgroup posters. And is it possible that MS delete microsoft.* hierarchy in Usenet, at least in backbone servers? I used the Community Bridge 3 a few years ago, for a little while. The "official" forum itself knows nothing at all about newsgroups and newsgroup posters. Microsoft shut down its news server many years ago. The NNTP bridge is a program you run locally on your own computer and which tries to emulate a local news server. The NNTP bridge communicates with the "official" forums using a REST web service. The REST web service is very different to NNTP, and therefore the news server emulation does not behave quite like a real news server. You will have to accept some compromises. You can still find microsoft.* hierarchy newsgroups on many Usenet servers, but Microsoft abandoned those newsgroups many years ago. -- Kind regards Ralph 山高自有客行路，水深自有渡船人。 -- 吴承恩 《西游记》
|
|
#5
March 6th 21, 02:23 PM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
|
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
On Sat, 06 Mar 2021 09:26:58 +1300, Ralph Fox wrote:
The Microsoft news server was shut down many years ago, but that is not relevant to the NNTP bridge. The NNTP bridge does not use the Microsoft news server. Ack, you're right. I forgot that Microsoft newsgroups don't require Microsoft's news server. And I forgot where I'm posting to... duh! ****[Diagram*best*viewed*in*a*fixed-pitch*font] [snip] So, the NNTP bridge is just an NNTP-to-HTTP proxy specifically for the web forum? I thought it was a web forum plugin which exposes Microsoft newsgroups from the web forum. i.e. to make the web forum also act as a web based NNTP client for Microsoft newsgroups.
|
|
#6
March 8th 21, 01:23 PM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
|
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
On 2021-3-6 5:09, Ralph Fox wrote:
... -- Kind regards Ralph 山高自有客行路，水深自有渡船人。 -- 吴承恩 《西游记》 Thanks and glad to see a chinese signature here! -- 久旱逢甘霖，他乡遇故知 Lu Wei IM: PGP: 0xA12FEF7592CCE1EA
|
|
#7
March 8th 21, 03:12 PM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
|
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
Ralph Fox wrote:
You can still find microsoft.* hierarchy newsgroups on many Usenet servers, but Microsoft abandoned those newsgroups many years ago. Due to peering, most Usenet providers continued carrying the microsoft.public.* newsgroups despite Microsoft shrunk away from Usenet (because they couldn't control it nor alter the standards to their wants). The users didn't abandon the microsoft.public.*. It was Microsoft that fled away. Microsoft's logic back then was their last version of Windows Server that included an NNTP server program (Windows Server 2003?) was discontinued hence unsupported, and Microsoft used it as an excuse to abandon Usenet. Microsoft refused to use a 3rd-party NNTP server, even free ones (e.g., INN) than many Usenet providers use. I do remember some self-appointed joker trying to claim Microsoft authority tried to cancel all posts to the microsoft.public.* newsgroups along with issuing requests to get the Usenet providers to remove the newsgroups. I recall only 1 Usenet provider complied with the bogus "Microsoft request". Everyone else didn't give a gnat's fart about the imposter, nor did they care Microsoft was leaving Usenet. Usenet doesn't require the permission of companies to have newsgroups created that focus on a company's products. Creating official newsgroups (in the Big-8 hierarchy) goes through a lengthy process, but deleting them is even harder. Alas, after Microsoft abandoned Usenet (but Usenet providers continued to carry the newsgroups), the MVPs gradually left Usenet. The boobs moved to the flat-filed web-based forums (Answers), so the MVPs followed where their expertise would be seen as greater by comparison to the forum community instead of back in Usenet. The MVPs followed the boobs move where they were needed to provide the most help.
|
|
#8
March 8th 21, 03:24 PM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
|
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
Ralph Fox wrote:
On Fri, 5 Mar 2021 13:28:37 +0800, Lu Wei wrote: Someone posted about the project: https://github.com/JochenKalmbach/communitybridge3 I wonder if the "official" forum is still friendly to newsgroup posters. And is it possible that MS delete microsoft.* hierarchy in Usenet, at least in backbone servers? I used the Community Bridge 3 a few years ago, for a little while. The "official" forum itself knows nothing at all about newsgroups and newsgroup posters. Microsoft shut down its news server many years ago. The NNTP bridge is a program you run locally on your own computer and which tries to emulate a local news server. The NNTP bridge communicates with the "official" forums using a REST web service. The REST web service is very different to NNTP, and therefore the news server emulation does not behave quite like a real news server. You will have to accept some compromises. You can still find microsoft.* hierarchy newsgroups on many Usenet servers, but Microsoft abandoned those newsgroups many years ago. I thought the NNTP bridge died several years ago. I recall trying it for a very short time -- because it was VERY flaky. https://archive.codeplex.com/?p=communitybridge Users are to download the NNTP bridge after 2021-JUL-1 from: https://github.com/JochenKalmbach/communitybridge Well, obviously Jochen Kalmbach decided to take up the codebase, because Microsoft decided to drop that NNTP access method. 3 years ago the project stalled. However, Kalmbach's code is a clone and has a datestamp of 5 years ago, so the NNTP bridge stalled that long ago. He grabbed the stale code before it disappears from CodePlex. Microsoft is not supporting it, and hasn't supported for many years. Considering how flaky it was several years ago when it was supported, but has been stale for several years, I wouldn't bother with it. Did they ever fix the Message-ID or References header problems? Does their web-based forum even bother to insert a References header to allow NNTP client to view hierarchy? Just use a web browser to their web forums instead of trying to interface your NNTP client to their forums.
|
|
#9
March 17th 21, 03:43 AM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
|
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
On 2021-3-8 23:12, VanguardLH wrote:
Due to peering, most Usenet providers continued carrying the microsoft.public.* newsgroups despite Microsoft shrunk away from Usenet (because they couldn't control it nor alter the standards to their wants). The users didn't abandon the microsoft.public.*. It was Microsoft that fled away. Microsoft's logic back then was their last version of Windows Server that included an NNTP server program (Windows Server 2003?) was discontinued hence unsupported, and Microsoft used it as an excuse to abandon Usenet. Microsoft refused to use a 3rd-party NNTP server, even free ones (e.g., INN) than many Usenet providers use. I do remember some self-appointed joker trying to claim Microsoft authority tried to cancel all posts to the microsoft.public.* newsgroups along with issuing requests to get the Usenet providers to remove the newsgroups. I recall only 1 Usenet provider complied with the bogus "Microsoft request". Everyone else didn't give a gnat's fart about the imposter, nor did they care Microsoft was leaving Usenet. Usenet doesn't require the permission of companies to have newsgroups created that focus on a company's products. Creating official newsgroups (in the Big-8 hierarchy) goes through a lengthy process, but deleting them is even harder. I don't have much knowledge about this. I suppose groups are deleted by such a process: one post a special control message, signed by the creator of the group, then the servers could automatically delete it as long as they have the initial creator's key, or they could verify that key through other ways. But, just as cancelling message function may be configured to be disabled, the servers may choose not to process any group deletion message, which is good sometimes (as group like this one), yet also may contributed to many zombie groups at present. -- Regards, Lu Wei IM: PGP: 0xA12FEF7592CCE1EA
|
|
#10
March 17th 21, 03:51 AM
posted to microsoft.public.windowsxp.general
|
|||
|
|||
|
Has anyone used MS official forum's NNTP bridge?
On 2021-3-8 23:24, VanguardLH wrote:
I thought the NNTP bridge died several years ago. I recall trying it for a very short time -- because it was VERY flaky. https://archive.codeplex.com/?p=communitybridge Users are to download the NNTP bridge after 2021-JUL-1 from: https://github.com/JochenKalmbach/communitybridge Well, obviously Jochen Kalmbach decided to take up the codebase, because Microsoft decided to drop that NNTP access method. 3 years ago the project stalled. However, Kalmbach's code is a clone and has a datestamp of 5 years ago, so the NNTP bridge stalled that long ago. He grabbed the stale code before it disappears from CodePlex. Microsoft is not supporting it, and hasn't supported for many years. Considering how flaky it was several years ago when it was supported, but has been stale for several years, I wouldn't bother with it. Did they ever fix the Message-ID or References header problems? Does their web-based forum even bother to insert a References header to allow NNTP client to view hierarchy? Just use a web browser to their web forums instead of trying to interface your NNTP client to their forums. The link I give is communitybridge3 (the third incarnation?), which has last commit 16 months ago. Anyway, I am just curious about it, not meant to try it; and since it needs .NET 4.6.2, my XP laptop should not run. -- Regards, Lu Wei IM: PGP: 0xA12FEF7592CCE1EA
|
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
|
|
Linear Mode
