A Windows XP help forum. PCbanter

If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Go Back   Home » PCbanter forum » Microsoft Windows XP » The Basics
Site Map Home Register Authors List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read Web Partners

xp upgrade from 98se



 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #31  
Old February 27th 05, 08:10 PM
Bruce Chambers
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se

JT wrote:


"Usually" being the operative word. Sorry, but I many others don't
wish to gamble seven plus years of software purchases, updates, and
data on "usually".



What's the gamble? In the rare instances where an upgrade doesn't
work, the computer is no worse off than if he'd prepared for a clean
installation.




The mistake that you and a few others make is the false assumption
that most users have the technical ability to make such backups.



It's no assumption. It takes little more intelligence to back up one's
data, than it does to pound sand. You're either grossly
under-estimating the intelligence of the average human, or vastly
over-exaggerating the difficulty of safely using a computer.


For
most users, your caveat to "have backups and anything else needed to
reinstall" would be virtually impossible to achieve without hands-on
expert assistance.



Nonsense. Are you saying that most computer users are too dim to
manage a few mouse-clicks or to master the concept of click-and-drag?
How, then, are they using their computers in the first place?



--

Bruce Chambers

Help us help you:
http://dts-l.org/goodpost.htm
http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html

You can have peace. Or you can have freedom. Don't ever count on having
both at once. - RAH
Ads
  #32  
Old February 27th 05, 08:32 PM
philo
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se


"Bruce Chambers" wrote in message
...
JT wrote:


"Usually" being the operative word. Sorry, but I many others don't
wish to gamble seven plus years of software purchases, updates, and
data on "usually".



What's the gamble? In the rare instances where an upgrade doesn't
work, the computer is no worse off than if he'd prepared for a clean
installation.



I think you missed the point...
although an upgrade generally does complete...
that does not guarantee a 100% working or stable system.
If the upgrade "hoses" the system...unless the drive was backed up...
there is nothing to go back to.
Unless the data itself was backed up...
at that point one would have to perform a clean install *without* formatting
etc
to at least keep the data.

In my opinion...the proper way to upgrade win98 to XP is to
first back up the data...and confirm its good.
Export any OE and IE data.(Netscaspe etc)
Then boot with the XP cd
and format the drive NTFS and do a clean install.
Reinstall the apps.
Import OE and IE data.(etc)
Copy the data to the appropriate folders.

Yes, it just may take a bit more work...
but there is little room for failure.


  #33  
Old February 27th 05, 10:03 PM
Colin Barnhorst
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se

The only advantage to formatting ntfs rather converting to ntfs later is
that the files system should run a little faster. However, even that can be
rectified with a boot time defragger such as the one in Diskeeper 9 Pro and
Perfect Disk which can defrag the file system in addition to the files.

This whole thread is simply too esoteric. Veterans to this newsgroup are
contantly encouraging users to back up their systems with all sorts of
backup programs, frequently Acronis or another imaging program. It cannot
be that hard to do, especially if the user has a dvd rewriter or a second
hard drive.

--
Colin Barnhorst [MVP Windows - Virtual Machine]
(Reply to the group only unless otherwise requested)
"philo" wrote in message
...

"Bruce Chambers" wrote in message
...
JT wrote:


"Usually" being the operative word. Sorry, but I many others don't
wish to gamble seven plus years of software purchases, updates, and
data on "usually".



What's the gamble? In the rare instances where an upgrade doesn't
work, the computer is no worse off than if he'd prepared for a clean
installation.



I think you missed the point...
although an upgrade generally does complete...
that does not guarantee a 100% working or stable system.
If the upgrade "hoses" the system...unless the drive was backed up...
there is nothing to go back to.
Unless the data itself was backed up...
at that point one would have to perform a clean install *without*
formatting
etc
to at least keep the data.

In my opinion...the proper way to upgrade win98 to XP is to
first back up the data...and confirm its good.
Export any OE and IE data.(Netscaspe etc)
Then boot with the XP cd
and format the drive NTFS and do a clean install.
Reinstall the apps.
Import OE and IE data.(etc)
Copy the data to the appropriate folders.

Yes, it just may take a bit more work...
but there is little room for failure.




  #34  
Old February 27th 05, 10:40 PM
Bruce Chambers
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se

philo wrote:




I think you missed the point...
although an upgrade generally does complete...
that does not guarantee a 100% working or stable system.



Neither does a clean installation.


If the upgrade "hoses" the system...unless the drive was backed up...
there is nothing to go back to.
Unless the data itself was backed up...



Which is why one always backs up data before making any serious changes
to an OS, including installing patches and service packs.




--

Bruce Chambers

Help us help you:
http://dts-l.org/goodpost.htm
http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html

You can have peace. Or you can have freedom. Don't ever count on having
both at once. - RAH
  #35  
Old February 27th 05, 11:16 PM
philo
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se


"Bruce Chambers" wrote in message
...
philo wrote:




I think you missed the point...
although an upgrade generally does complete...
that does not guarantee a 100% working or stable system.



Neither does a clean installation.


If the upgrade "hoses" the system...unless the drive was backed up...
there is nothing to go back to.
Unless the data itself was backed up...



Which is why one always backs up data before making any serious changes
to an OS, including installing patches and service packs.




Hey guys...
you've all made some great points...
and though I may not agree with everyone 100%...
I just wanted to say how refreshing it was to talk to everyone in an
intelligent and cool manner.
None of the stupid name calling and inane comments found on some of the
other news
groups.
A real pleasure
and thanks for the great discussion!


  #36  
Old February 27th 05, 11:50 PM
Ken Blake
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se

In ,
JT typed:

"Ken Blake" wrote:

Unlike with previous versions of Windows, an upgrade to XP
replaces almost everything, and usually works very well.


"Usually" being the operative word. Sorry, but I many others
don't
wish to gamble seven plus years of software purchases, updates,
and
data on "usually".



I certainly don't think that you should gamble anything, and
nowhere did I suggest that.



However, don't assume that doing an upgrade relieves you of
the
need to backup your data, etc. before beginning. Before
starting
to upgrade, it's always prudent to recognize that things like
a
sudden power loss can occur in the middle of it and cause the
loss of everything. For that reason you should make sure you
have
backups and anything else you need to reinstall if the worst
happens.


The mistake that you and a few others make is the false
assumption
that most users have the technical ability to make such
backups.



I think you miss the critical point entirely. Backup is
essential, whether you are doing an upgrade or not. Not having a
backup is *always* "gambl[ing] seven plus years of software
purchases, updates, and data" and is a foolhardy thing to do.

Although making backups is generally easy and well within the
technical skills of most beginners I know (with a little help to
get started), I make no assumptions about what technical
abilities most users have. But anyone who doesn't have that
ability desparately needs to acquire it. It's not hard to learn
and is a far greater need than upgrading your version of Windows.



For
most users, your caveat to "have backups and anything else
needed to
reinstall" would be virtually impossible to achieve without
hands-on
expert assistance.



Nonsense! That's not at all true in my experience. There may be
an occasional person like that, but the great majority of
beginners I'ved worked with have easily learned to do backups
with just a little help from me.


No, the safest way to effect an XP Pro upgrade is
to first have someone who knows what they are doing either
image the
drive(s) beforehand and store the image externally or clone the
drive(s) beforehand. That way, reverting back to a working
Win98
system is just a matter of restoring the image or swapping
drives.



That's one form of backup, and it happens to be a good one for
many people. It's the method I personally use. But it's not the
only choice.

--
Ken Blake - Microsoft MVP Windows: Shell/User
Please reply to the newsgroup


  #37  
Old February 27th 05, 11:57 PM
Ken Blake
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se

In ,
philo typed:

"Usually works" and "almost as good" are not words in my
vocabulary!



Then you need to enrich your vocabulary. The point I was making
when I said "usually works" was that because it "usually works,"
it makes sense to try that way first. If it doesn't work, you can
always revert to a clean installation.

Do you own a car? Does it always work or does it "usually work"?
Do you refrain from using it because it only "usually works"?

Is your car a Ford (substitute Chevrolet, Toyota, or whatever you
have)? Why don't you have a Rolls-Royce (substitute Ferrari,
Maserati, or whatever you think is the best)? Your Ford (or
whatever) is only "almost as good."

"Usually works" and "almost as good" are facts of life. Nothing
is guaranteed to work all the time, and very few of us have the
luxury of being able to always buy the best of everything.

--
Ken Blake - Microsoft MVP Windows: Shell/User
Please reply to the newsgroup


  #38  
Old February 28th 05, 12:01 AM
Ken Blake
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se

In ,
philo typed:

"Bruce Chambers" wrote in
message
...
JT wrote:


"Usually" being the operative word. Sorry, but I many others
don't
wish to gamble seven plus years of software purchases,
updates, and
data on "usually".



What's the gamble? In the rare instances where an upgrade
doesn't
work, the computer is no worse off than if he'd prepared for a
clean
installation.



I think you missed the point...
although an upgrade generally does complete...
that does not guarantee a 100% working or stable system.
If the upgrade "hoses" the system...unless the drive was backed
up...
there is nothing to go back to.



On the contrary, I think you're the one who missed the point.
Bruce's comment was in reply to JT's reply to my message
recommending at least *trying* an upgrade first, but *only*
after first making a backup. I said "However, don't assume that
doing an upgrade relieves you of the need to backup your data,
etc. before beginning. Before starting to upgrade, it's always
prudent to recognize that things like a sudden power loss can
occur in the middle of it and cause the loss of everything. For
that reason you should make sure you have backups and anything
else you need to reinstall if the worst happens."

--
Ken Blake - Microsoft MVP Windows: Shell/User
Please reply to the newsgroup


  #39  
Old February 28th 05, 12:47 AM
philo
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se


"Ken Blake" wrote in message
...
In ,
philo typed:

"Usually works" and "almost as good" are not words in my
vocabulary!



Then you need to enrich your vocabulary. The point I was making
when I said "usually works" was that because it "usually works,"
it makes sense to try that way first. If it doesn't work, you can
always revert to a clean installation.


As long as your important data is backed up...I have no problem with
your statement

Do you own a car? Does it always work or does it "usually work"?
Do you refrain from using it because it only "usually works"?
Is your car a Ford (substitute Chevrolet, Toyota, or whatever you
have)? Why don't you have a Rolls-Royce (substitute Ferrari,
Maserati, or whatever you think is the best)? Your Ford (or
whatever) is only "almost as good."

"Usually works" and "almost as good" are facts of life. Nothing
is guaranteed to work all the time, and very few of us have the
luxury of being able to always buy the best of everything.


Now you may not believe this, but I do not own a car (or a TV)...
however i do have a "company van" .It now has close to 90,000 miles on it
and has *never* failed yet...I keep it maintained very well...better than if
I owned my own car.

Same with my computer systems... If one goes down for maintenance or an
upgrade...
I have quite a few more that can go on-line... so I am *never* without a
working computer
here...generally I have over a dozen ready to go on-line at any time.
Also have 3 UPS systems and enough batteries to run everything for over 48
hours.
Maybe I am a bit too over-cautious...
I wear a belt but no suspenders...so as you can see...I am willing to take
an occasional risk


here are links to *some* of my backup systems

www.plazaearth.com/philo/comps.jpg

www.plazaearth.com/philo/batt.jpg


  #40  
Old February 28th 05, 01:16 AM
Ken Blake
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se

In ,
philo typed:

"Ken Blake" wrote in message
...
In ,
philo typed:

"Usually works" and "almost as good" are not words in my
vocabulary!



Then you need to enrich your vocabulary. The point I was
making
when I said "usually works" was that because it "usually
works,"
it makes sense to try that way first. If it doesn't work, you
can
always revert to a clean installation.


As long as your important data is backed up...I have no problem
with
your statement



Then it would seem that we basically agree. Having a backup was
an important part of my recommendation.

--
Ken Blake - Microsoft MVP Windows: Shell/User
Please reply to the newsgroup


  #41  
Old February 28th 05, 01:28 AM
philo
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se


"Ken Blake" wrote in message
...
In ,
philo typed:

"Ken Blake" wrote in message
...
In ,
philo typed:

"Usually works" and "almost as good" are not words in my
vocabulary!


Then you need to enrich your vocabulary. The point I was
making
when I said "usually works" was that because it "usually
works,"
it makes sense to try that way first. If it doesn't work, you
can
always revert to a clean installation.


As long as your important data is backed up...I have no problem
with
your statement



Then it would seem that we basically agree. Having a backup was
an important part of my recommendation.



yes..
it was not all that long ago that i had an extreme phobia of computers
and was just using a manual typewriter...
then thanks to my girlfriend who gave me her old computer...
i was bitten by the bug...and lurked (and occasionally posted) on some of
the win98
groups...
i got a *lot* of good advice from you (and others) and doubt if i ever
thanked you

so now, five years later: Thanks!!!!


  #42  
Old February 28th 05, 04:27 AM
Ken Blake
external usenet poster
 
Posts: n/a
Default xp upgrade from 98se

In ,
philo typed:
"Ken Blake" wrote in message
...
In ,
philo typed:

"Ken Blake" wrote in
message
...
In ,
philo typed:

"Usually works" and "almost as good" are not words in my
vocabulary!


Then you need to enrich your vocabulary. The point I was
making
when I said "usually works" was that because it "usually
works,"
it makes sense to try that way first. If it doesn't work,
you
can
always revert to a clean installation.


As long as your important data is backed up...I have no
problem
with
your statement



Then it would seem that we basically agree. Having a backup
was
an important part of my recommendation.



yes..
it was not all that long ago that i had an extreme phobia of
computers
and was just using a manual typewriter...
then thanks to my girlfriend who gave me her old computer...
i was bitten by the bug...and lurked (and occasionally posted)
on
some of the win98
groups...
i got a *lot* of good advice from you (and others) and doubt if
i ever
thanked you

so now, five years later: Thanks!!!!



Thanks very much for the kind words, and you're most welcome.


 




Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Upgrade To HomeXP from 98SE JE General XP issues or comments 3 January 10th 05 03:24 PM
Not "burning" to Cd after SP2 upgrade \old\ devildog Windows XP Help and Support 0 November 30th 04 06:18 PM
Not able to "burn" to Cd after SP2 upgrade \old\ devildog General XP issues or comments 0 November 30th 04 06:14 PM
Mysterious Fatal Error during upgrade from 98SE to XP. Why??? Kevo New Users to Windows XP 2 October 16th 04 03:32 PM
Mysterious Fatal Error Message during upgrade from 98SE to XP. Why Kevo Windows XP Help and Support 1 October 16th 04 08:41 AM






All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:28 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004-2024 PCbanter.
The comments are property of their posters.