classic shell vs Retro UI

On Wed, 31 Oct 2012 14:54:24 -0700, "Gene E. Bloch"
wrote:

On Wed, 31 Oct 2012 07:51:02 -0700, Ken Blake wrote:

On Wed, 31 Oct 2012 08:36:16 -0500, "R. C. White"
wrote:


That's why I usually hold down the RIGHT mouse button while Copying or
Moving files. Nothing gets committed until I release the button, giving me
time to read the popup showing the actual destination. And, even after the
release, it lets me choose between Copy and Move (or Cancel), giving me a
last chance to verify the destination, too.

I do the same thing, RC. I do it for the commitment reason you
mention, but mainly because I find it hard to remember under what
condition drag-and-drop means "copy" and under what conditions it
means "move." With right-drag, I don't have to remember.

Feel free to forget the following :-)

If it's to the same partition, without control it's move and with
control it's copy.

If it's to another partition, it's the reverse.

It seems that Microsoft thinks you normally want to move a file when
you're dragging it within your partition, whereas you normally want to
copy a file when you're dragging it between partitions.

I have the advantage of remembering that, but in truth, I don't like it
very much.


Yes, thanks. I've read those rules when I've read them before. But
because I see no logic in it, I find it hard to remember. So I choose
to right-drag.


Before I forget: on my W7 system, when I am dragging a file, there is an
icon on the mouse cursor that shows whether the OS plans to move the
file or to copy it.


Yes, same on Windows 8.


I try to remember to look at that icon before
releasing the mouse button.


Yes, but to me, *trying* to remember is dangerous. I want to know for
sure. And again, that's why I right-drag.


--
Ken Blake