If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. |
|
|
|
Thread Tools | Rate Thread | Display Modes |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
Robin Bignall wrote:
On Thu, 28 Jun 2012 17:14:45 -0400, Paul wrote: Gene E. Bloch wrote: It would be nice if they gave some reasons or some anecdotal evidence for not using the program. But anyway, I don't plan to use it :-) For me, it's a matter of the "trust chain". I trust a RealTek driver I get directly from the RealTek site. I don't trust a driver that comes from the Driver Helper server. While good AV software can catch things known to exist, nothing would stop the owner of the Driver Helper site from inserting their own custom malware. So it's a matter of trust. Or expense, for the ones that charge money for the privilege of (trying to) identify your drivers for you. In one of those driver programs, the menu offered after the scan, had roughly twice as many drivers listed, as were actually needed. So some of the programs "plump up the menu", to make like they're doing you a big favor. ******* On my WinXP machine, I don't even take the drivers off the Windows Update menu, because 9 times out of 10, the version doesn't exist in the wild, and there's something wrong with it. It's possible the ones offered in Windows 7, aren't quite as obscure in terms of versioning. I got a driver once from Microsoft (default ATI driver for my video card, on the installer CD), that only operated one of the two display channels on the card. If you played a 3D game, and alt-tabbed out, all acceleration in the desktop was disabled. That's the kind of thing Microsoft distributes. Well... tested... stuff... I bought the commercial version. It downloads the drivers, they're subjected to the usual virus check for anything downloaded, and you CHOOSE whether to install them. Each driver has full details of where it came from, version, date etc. and you can check back to the source to verify veracity. So when you look at the file name, do you see something similar offered in the HDaudio section of the RealTek site ? Motherboard audio solutions (at least for recent systems), are either AC'97 (five years ago) or HDAudio (modern). The RealTek HDAudio driver should be a "jumbo" driver, which handles most all of their HDAudio sound chips. Some chips in the past were PCI, and an enthusiast sound solution from years ago, might have included a PCI chip soldered to the motherboard. But for most of the rest, they're the simpler AC'97 or HDAudio, where there's no intelligence to speak of, and the chip functions as an "audio pipe". You send samples to the chip, and it has ADC and DACs for making analog voltages to/from the samples. The audio driver package, will usually have a huge .inf file. And that file includes mappings from chip facilities, to the port wiring on the motherboard. If a chip supports "three jack" and "six jack" installations, the .inf file helps sort out and get the jack assignments right. Paul |
Ads |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
On Thu, 28 Jun 2012 17:14:45 -0400, Paul wrote:
Gene E. Bloch wrote: It would be nice if they gave some reasons or some anecdotal evidence for not using the program. But anyway, I don't plan to use it :-) For me, it's a matter of the "trust chain". I trust a RealTek driver I get directly from the RealTek site. I don't trust a driver that comes from the Driver Helper server. While good AV software can catch things known to exist, nothing would stop the owner of the Driver Helper site from inserting their own custom malware. So it's a matter of trust. Or expense, for the ones that charge money for the privilege of (trying to) identify your drivers for you. In one of those driver programs, the menu offered after the scan, had roughly twice as many drivers listed, as were actually needed. So some of the programs "plump up the menu", to make like they're doing you a big favor. ******* On my WinXP machine, I don't even take the drivers off the Windows Update menu, because 9 times out of 10, the version doesn't exist in the wild, and there's something wrong with it. It's possible the ones offered in Windows 7, aren't quite as obscure in terms of versioning. I got a driver once from Microsoft (default ATI driver for my video card, on the installer CD), that only operated one of the two display channels on the card. If you played a 3D game, and alt-tabbed out, all acceleration in the desktop was disabled. That's the kind of thing Microsoft distributes. Well... tested... stuff... Paul You and Char have now given reasons, and thank you both for that, but what my post meant by "they" was the posters on the forum that Char pointed to. The posts there essentially just said "Don't use it" without hinting at any reasons. -- Gene E. Bloch (Stumbling Bloch) |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
On Thu, 28 Jun 2012 18:15:30 -0400, Paul wrote:
Robin Bignall wrote: On Thu, 28 Jun 2012 17:14:45 -0400, Paul wrote: Gene E. Bloch wrote: It would be nice if they gave some reasons or some anecdotal evidence for not using the program. But anyway, I don't plan to use it :-) For me, it's a matter of the "trust chain". I trust a RealTek driver I get directly from the RealTek site. I don't trust a driver that comes from the Driver Helper server. While good AV software can catch things known to exist, nothing would stop the owner of the Driver Helper site from inserting their own custom malware. So it's a matter of trust. Or expense, for the ones that charge money for the privilege of (trying to) identify your drivers for you. In one of those driver programs, the menu offered after the scan, had roughly twice as many drivers listed, as were actually needed. So some of the programs "plump up the menu", to make like they're doing you a big favor. ******* On my WinXP machine, I don't even take the drivers off the Windows Update menu, because 9 times out of 10, the version doesn't exist in the wild, and there's something wrong with it. It's possible the ones offered in Windows 7, aren't quite as obscure in terms of versioning. I got a driver once from Microsoft (default ATI driver for my video card, on the installer CD), that only operated one of the two display channels on the card. If you played a 3D game, and alt-tabbed out, all acceleration in the desktop was disabled. That's the kind of thing Microsoft distributes. Well... tested... stuff... I bought the commercial version. It downloads the drivers, they're subjected to the usual virus check for anything downloaded, and you CHOOSE whether to install them. Each driver has full details of where it came from, version, date etc. and you can check back to the source to verify veracity. So when you look at the file name, do you see something similar offered in the HDaudio section of the RealTek site ? The version names do not match. That's why I had trouble with downloading anything from Realtek, but... see below... Motherboard audio solutions (at least for recent systems), are either AC'97 (five years ago) or HDAudio (modern). The RealTek HDAudio driver should be a "jumbo" driver, which handles most all of their HDAudio sound chips. Some chips in the past were PCI, and an enthusiast sound solution from years ago, might have included a PCI chip soldered to the motherboard. But for most of the rest, they're the simpler AC'97 or HDAudio, where there's no intelligence to speak of, and the chip functions as an "audio pipe". You send samples to the chip, and it has ADC and DACs for making analog voltages to/from the samples. The audio driver package, will usually have a huge .inf file. And that file includes mappings from chip facilities, to the port wiring on the motherboard. If a chip supports "three jack" and "six jack" installations, the .inf file helps sort out and get the jack assignments right. I picked out the latest Win 7,8, Vista driver from Realtek (50 GB) and installed it. It works but there's still the mismatch with Dolby. Exactly the same message. -- Robin Bignall Herts, England |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 21:21:22 +0100, Robin Bignall
wrote: I picked out the latest Win 7,8, Vista driver from Realtek (50 GB) and installed it. It works but there's still the mismatch with Dolby. Exactly the same message. 50GB? :-) Probably 50 MB. -- Char Jackson |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 21:21:22 +0100, Robin Bignall
wrote: I picked out the latest Win 7,8, Vista driver from Realtek (50 GB) and installed it. It works but there's still the mismatch with Dolby. Exactly the same message. Incidentally, the latest Realtek driver according to Hardware Helper is 6.0.1.6649. The one I just downloaded from Realtek is 6.0.1.6662. Both of these are about 50 mB. The one on the Realtek site is 6.0.1.6554, and is over 100 mB, the difference, presumably, being Dolby. -- Robin Bignall Herts, England |
#21
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 23:25:07 +0100, Robin Bignall
wrote: On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 21:21:22 +0100, Robin Bignall wrote: I picked out the latest Win 7,8, Vista driver from Realtek (50 GB) and installed it. It works but there's still the mismatch with Dolby. Exactly the same message. Incidentally, the latest Realtek driver according to Hardware Helper is 6.0.1.6649. The one I just downloaded from Realtek is 6.0.1.6662. Both of these are about 50 mB. The one on the Realtek site is 6.0.1.6554, and is over 100 mB, the difference, presumably, being Dolby. You still haven't ditched that silly Hardware Helper? What's taking so long? BTW, mB = millibytes, a unit of measurement not in common usage. You probably mean MB (megabytes). I guess I'm not being very helpful. -- Char Jackson |
#22
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
Robin Bignall wrote:
On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 21:21:22 +0100, Robin Bignall wrote: I picked out the latest Win 7,8, Vista driver from Realtek (50 GB) and installed it. It works but there's still the mismatch with Dolby. Exactly the same message. Incidentally, the latest Realtek driver according to Hardware Helper is 6.0.1.6649. The one I just downloaded from Realtek is 6.0.1.6662. Both of these are about 50 mB. The one on the Realtek site is 6.0.1.6554, and is over 100 mB, the difference, presumably, being Dolby. Can the files be opened with 7-ZIP ? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7-zip That's how I take various drivers apart, compare them, and so on. Not all drivers can be disassembled easily. Some are Installshield, with encrypted CABs inside. Others, they use a "packer", like UPX, at the top level, and then 7-ZIP won't open them at all. So actually being able to guarantee disassembly is pretty difficult. Too many techniques to obscure them. On occasion, I use WINE in a Linux virtual machine, to crack open an installer. With less danger to my running Windows OS. So that's another forensic technique that works sometimes. I use that for webcam drivers from Chinese sites, the ones where you wonder whether they're infected or not. For dodgy sites, you can also upload the file to virustotal.com and scan it there. I believe I had one Chinese webcam driver, that "smelled bad". I'd like to help you, but I really don't understand how the software knows Dolby stuff is to be installed or not. I can't really simulate that here. Paul |
#23
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
"Paul" wrote in message ... Can the files be opened with 7-ZIP ? That's how I take various drivers apart, compare them, and so on. Not all drivers can be disassembled easily. Some are Installshield, with encrypted CABs inside. Others, they use a "packer", like UPX, at the top level, and then 7-ZIP won't open them at all. So actually being able to guarantee disassembly is pretty difficult. Too many techniques to obscure them. On occasion, I use WINE in a Linux virtual machine, to crack open an installer. With less danger to my running Windows OS. So that's another forensic technique that works sometimes. I use that for webcam drivers from Chinese sites, the ones where you wonder whether they're infected or not. For dodgy sites, you can also upload the file to virustotal.com and scan it there. I believe I had one Chinese webcam driver, that "smelled bad". Paul I use Uniextract to unpack installers and other packed files: http://legroom.net/software/uniextract/ And for Inno packed installers I use this Inno Setup Unpacker method: http://sourceforge.net/projects/inno.../topic/1122068 |
#24
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 18:02:53 -0500, Char Jackson
wrote: On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 23:25:07 +0100, Robin Bignall wrote: On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 21:21:22 +0100, Robin Bignall wrote: I picked out the latest Win 7,8, Vista driver from Realtek (50 GB) and installed it. It works but there's still the mismatch with Dolby. Exactly the same message. Incidentally, the latest Realtek driver according to Hardware Helper is 6.0.1.6649. The one I just downloaded from Realtek is 6.0.1.6662. Both of these are about 50 mB. The one on the Realtek site is 6.0.1.6554, and is over 100 mB, the difference, presumably, being Dolby. You still haven't ditched that silly Hardware Helper? What's taking so long? BTW, mB = millibytes, a unit of measurement not in common usage. You probably mean MB (megabytes). I guess I'm not being very helpful. Not particularly, and HH has served me well enough for a couple of years. This Dolby business and the licensing is a weird case. -- Robin Bignall Herts, England |
#25
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 19:12:04 -0400, Paul wrote:
Robin Bignall wrote: On Fri, 29 Jun 2012 21:21:22 +0100, Robin Bignall wrote: I picked out the latest Win 7,8, Vista driver from Realtek (50 GB) and installed it. It works but there's still the mismatch with Dolby. Exactly the same message. Incidentally, the latest Realtek driver according to Hardware Helper is 6.0.1.6649. The one I just downloaded from Realtek is 6.0.1.6662. Both of these are about 50 mB. The one on the Realtek site is 6.0.1.6554, and is over 100 mB, the difference, presumably, being Dolby. Can the files be opened with 7-ZIP ? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/7-zip I noticed that the Gigabyte one used 7-Zip to unscramble itself. I didn't see any unscrambling for the others. They all used InstallShield in a two-step process: uninstall the old reboot install the new That's how I take various drivers apart, compare them, and so on. Not all drivers can be disassembled easily. Some are Installshield, with encrypted CABs inside. Others, they use a "packer", like UPX, at the top level, and then 7-ZIP won't open them at all. So actually being able to guarantee disassembly is pretty difficult. Too many techniques to obscure them. On occasion, I use WINE in a Linux virtual machine, to crack open an installer. With less danger to my running Windows OS. So that's another forensic technique that works sometimes. I use that for webcam drivers from Chinese sites, the ones where you wonder whether they're infected or not. For dodgy sites, you can also upload the file to virustotal.com and scan it there. I believe I had one Chinese webcam driver, that "smelled bad". I'd like to help you, but I really don't understand how the software knows Dolby stuff is to be installed or not. I can't really simulate that here. The latest Gigabyte driver is working fine, except that Dolby doesn't load automatically on booting. The rest of the technicalities are well above my pay grade, but thanks for some great insight. -- Robin Bignall Herts, England |
#26
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
Robin Bignall wrote on 06/27/2012 16:17 ET :
I installed latest Realtek driver and now Dolby Home Theatre tells me drivers do not match. Can't find any downloads on Dolby site, not any mention of Dolby on motherboard driver disk. Any ideas? Robin Bignall Herts, England Hi, I don't know if it would solve the "out of sync" problem bescribed in this topic, but I didn't see if anybody write about that the Dolby Home Theatre works just fine with newer Realtek drivers actually. I think that only interface is not working and gives that error about 7.2.7000 vs 7.2.8000. Try this: Go to Playback devices in Windows 7 Start-Control Panel - Sound Click RMB on Speakers or Digital Output (whatever you have) and than Properties At the top you should have Dolby tab where Dolby Home Theatre v4 interface is. |
#27
|
|||
|
|||
realtek and dolby out of sync
On Thu, 01 Nov 2012 08:11:12 -0500, solver
wrote: Robin Bignall wrote on 06/27/2012 16:17 ET : I installed latest Realtek driver and now Dolby Home Theatre tells me drivers do not match. Can't find any downloads on Dolby site, not any mention of Dolby on motherboard driver disk. Any ideas? Robin Bignall Herts, England Hi, I don't know if it would solve the "out of sync" problem bescribed in this topic, but I didn't see if anybody write about that the Dolby Home Theatre works just fine with newer Realtek drivers actually. I think that only interface is not working and gives that error about 7.2.7000 vs 7.2.8000. Try this: Go to Playback devices in Windows 7 Start-Control Panel - Sound Click RMB on Speakers or Digital Output (whatever you have) and than Properties At the top you should have Dolby tab where Dolby Home Theatre v4 interface is. Thanks for getting back to me on this. Following the instructions I get "Current Dolby driver is 7.2.8000.13. Software application expects 7.2.7000.4" Downloads of Realtek drivers from Realtek do not contain Dolby drivers, AFAIK. I have a Gigabyte board, and downloading the Gigabyte sound driver is supposed to consist of two drivers, Realtek and Dolby, that install one after the other. The latest one I downloaded didn't. I have all of the past Realtek drivers on disk and I suppose I could go back through them until I found a match, but it's too much trouble. I only have two desktop speakers. -- Robin Bignall Herts, England |
|
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | Rate This Thread |
|
|